Nature on Nantucket & Mount Desert Island

Many luxury destinations feature tropical sights or world-renowned architecture, while others offer a more quaint experience and immerse visitors in nature and history. Such locations in the United States include Nantucket, Massachusetts, and Mount Desert Island, Maine, two islands known for their historical charm and pristine natural environments. The latter allows visitors to find a balance between quiet getaway and adventure, while Nantucket’s atmosphere, boutique hotels, and beautiful beaches make it one of the best islands for peaceful relaxation.

Originally a whaling community, Nantucket committed to preserving its environment and history as tourism grew. Today, its small towns and villages retain an Old-World ambience through land conservation programs, strict new construction regulations, and cultural sites that pay homage to its heritage. They also boast cobblestone paths and a broad selection of family-owned shops. In addition to maintaining the island’s connection to its Quaker roots, these characteristics provide Nantucket with an overall relaxed vibe as a travel location.

In contrast, Mount Desert Island’s preservation efforts primarily involve maintaining historical buildings. Its towns also exhibit distinct personalities and vary in energy level. The tourist hub of Bar Harbor offers a bustling assortment of shopping and dining, while the island’s western half harbors a quieter atmosphere. Home to some of the Atlantic coast’s highest seaside summits, Mount Desert Island also provides a remote respite from civilization via its multiple mountains and expansive natural landscapes. This includes Acadia National Park, the only natural park in Maine.

The pristine nature and presence of coastal villages on Nantucket and Mount Desert Island present options for outdoor activities at both destinations. Acadia National Park spans much of Mount Desert Island, where people can partake in scenic coastal drives, go fishing, or traverse a multitude of hiking trails.

Nantucket holds a reputation as a biker’s paradise due to its network of biking paths, and its lack of coastal summits allows for a more traditional summer vacation with public and private beaches. Moreover, both islands offer shopping spots, fresh seafood, and boat tours and charters.

Travelers will find luxurious places for an overnight stay regardless of which island they choose. Nantucket features a growing assortment of resorts and boutique hotels, which include The Wauwinet, the iconic White Elephant Nantucket, and The Nantucket Hotel & Resort. For a more unique experience, the Nantucket Resort Collection utilizes a three-in-one concept through three properties with distinct styles and offerings.

On Mount Desert Island, the historic waterfront hotels account for the best places to stay. Balance Rock Inn in Bar Harbor places guests within close proximity of the island’s main tourist area, and The Asticou Inn in the quieter Northeast Harbor is a favorite of celebrities like Ariana Rockefeller and Martha Stewart. Additionally, travelers can book a room at one of Mount Desert Island’s many bed and breakfasts.

When planning a trip, Nantucket requires more consideration regarding the time of year to visit than Mount Desert Island does because most of Nantucket’s hotels close for the winter. Visiting in the summer allows for greater enjoyment of this island’s beaches and seaside attractions, but temperatures reach their peak in July and August. To avoid crowds and experience the water at its warmest, many guides suggest waiting until September for a trip to Nantucket.

Mount Desert Island is a less seasonal travel destination due to the availability of summer and winter activities, particularly in Acadia National Park. Snowfall transforms its carriage trails into optimal passages for cross-country skiing and make the park loop road a coveted spot for snowmobiling. The park also features many ice climbing routes.